Pizza in Valley Cottage

Explore the full pizza menu at Valley Pizza in Valley Cottage, NY, with convenient pickup available for every craving.

Order online

Popular Pizza to Try

Plain Slice

$3.50

A classic pizza slice with cheese and tomato sauce.

“Suprisingly good pizza. REALLY solid with tons of options.”

Chicken Supreme Pizza

$22.00+

Pizza topped with chicken, peppers, and onions in a chosen size.

“Great slices! Lots of options, garlic knots slider sandwiches look amazing. Will be back for more 🍕🍕🍕”

Grandma Pizza

$24.00

A square grandma-style pizza with optional sauce, cheese, and toppings.

“Valley Pizza is our number one spot for ordering lunch. The service is friendly and professional, the delivery is fast, and the pizza is delicious. Definitely recommend!”

Find Something Special at Valley Pizza

Valley Pizza in Valley Cottage, NY serves a wide-ranging pizza menu, from classic pies to gourmet creations and grandma-style deep dish options for every appetite.

Crowd-pleasing choices include the Meat Lover Pizza, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza, Vodka Margherita Pizza, The Works Pizza, and the Chicken Pepperoni Alfredo Pizza (AKA "The ChickenRoni"), each available in your preferred size.

Whether you dine-in, order pickup, arrange delivery, or plan ahead with catering, Valley Pizza makes it easy to enjoy great pizza right in Valley Cottage, NY.

Pizza to Try

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

$22.00+

Pizza with Buffalo-style chicken flavor; choose a small or large size.

“An excellent experience. From the warm reception by the staff to the nice ambiance including the led lights this place is incredible. The mozzarella sticks were perfectly crispy and cheesy, the garlic knots were delicious, the pizza was flat, no flop, crispy and flavorful…..an 8.1 which is a proper score and finally the chicken parmigiana with steamed vegetables was cooked perfectly and simply tasty. I’ve eaten at hundreds of Italian restaurants over the decades and highly endorse Valley Pizza in Valley Cottage.”

Chicken Francese Pizza

$23.00+

Pizza featuring chicken Francese, with a required choice of small or large.

“The pizza is perfectly thin with just the right amount of cheese. My family loves it. Friendly, reliable and accommodating service.”

Grandma Buffalo Pizza

$24.00

Grandma-style pizza with Buffalo-style flavor and optional toppings.

“Valley Pizza is the BEST in the County! It is Beyond and Very Much Like NYC Pizza if not Better! Beyond Fresh & Delicious! Staff are Amazing! I say this review as a regular guest. (-:)”

BBQ Chicken Pizza

$22.00+

Pizza featuring chicken and barbecue sauce on a baked pizza crust.

Buffalo Chicken Slice

$4.75

A pizza slice topped with buffalo chicken and spicy buffalo sauce.

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

$22.00+

Pizza topped with chicken, bacon, and ranch-style dressing.

Chicken Bacon Ranch Slice

$4.75

A pizza slice topped with chicken, bacon, and ranch dressing.

Chicken Marsala Pizza

$23.00+

Pizza with chicken and Marsala-style sauce, offered in two sizes.

Chicken Parm Pizza

$22.00+

A chicken Parmesan-style pizza available in small or large sizes.

Fresh Tomato & Mozzarella

$24.00

A grandma-style pizza featuring fresh tomato and mozzarella.

Grandma BBQ Pizza

$24.00

A deep-dish pizza featuring barbecue sauce.

Margherita Pizza

$22.00+

Pizza topped with tomato, mozzarella, and basil; choose a size.

Penne Vodka Pizza

$21.00+

Pizza topped with penne pasta and creamy tomato-vodka sauce.

Pizza

$17.00+

A 14-inch pizza cut into six slices, with optional toppings.

Salad Pie

$22.00+

A salad-topped pizza with a required Small or Large size.

Salad Slice

$5.00

A pizza slice topped with salad-style ingredients.

Vodka Margherita Pizza

$22.00+

Margherita pizza with vodka sauce and a choice of small or large.

Cauliflower Crust Pizza

$14.00

Personal-size pizza baked on a cauliflower crust with optional toppings.

“Consistently delicious pizza”

Gluten Free Pizza

$14.00

Personal-size pizza on a gluten-free crust with optional toppings.

“I used to not like pizza, but this place makes their pizzas so phenomenal, its absolutely remarkable their garlic breads as well. This place is a must go, now i crave pizza almost all the time”

Vodkarita Slice

$4.75

A specialty pizza slice served under the Vodkarita name.

“Love Valley Pizza.. definitely my go to spot for za.. Vodkarita slices are on point . Still waiting for the Big Mac pie Chef... 😉”

18" Sicilian Pizza

$21.00

An 18-inch Sicilian pizza cut into eight slices.

Chicken Parm Slice

$4.75

A pizza slice topped with chicken Parmesan-style ingredients.

Chicken Pepperoni Alfredo Pizza

$24.00

Grandma-style deep-dish pizza with chicken, pepperoni, and Alfredo sauce.

Eggplant Marinara Pizza

$24.00

Grandma-style deep-dish pizza topped with eggplant and marinara sauce.

Fresca Pizza

$24.00

Fresca Pizza is a grandma-style deep-dish pizza with optional toppings.

Hawaiian Pie

$22.00+

A pizza with ham and pineapple as its defining toppings.

Margherita Slice

$4.75

A pizza slice topped with tomato, mozzarella, and basil.

Meat Lover Pizza

$22.00+

A pizza topped with pepperoni, meatball, sausage, and bacon.

Original Stuffed Cheesesteak Pie

$30.00

A stuffed deep-dish pizza built around a cheesesteak-style filling.

Sicilian Slice

$4.00

A thick, square Sicilian pizza slice with a substantial baked crust.

Sicilian Slice with 1 Topping

$4.50

A thick Sicilian pizza slice finished with one selected topping.

Taco Pizza

$22.00+

Pizza topped with ground beef, sour cream, lettuce, tomato, and cheddar.

The Works Pizza

$22.00+

Meatball, sausage, pepperoni, peppers, onions, olives, mushrooms top pizza.

White Pizza

$19.00+

A cheese-forward white pizza with optional toppings and sauce adjustments.

White Slice

$4.75

A plain cheese pizza slice with a white, sauce-free topping.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular pizza options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

Pizza — This 14-inch pizza arrives cut into six slices, with optional toppings available for personal customization.
Plain Slice — This straightforward slice features cheese and tomato sauce on a baked pizza crust for a classic slice.
Original Stuffed Cheesesteak Pie — This deep-dish pizza has a stuffed cheesesteak-style center, while toppings such as bacon or onions can be added.
Chicken Francese Pizza — This pizza includes chicken Francese and requires selecting either the small or large size option.
Chicken Supreme Pizza — This pizza features chicken, peppers, and onions, with a required choice between small and large sizes.

Do you offer delivery and takeout?

Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for pizza throughout the Valley Cottage area. Order your pizza online for convenient pickup or delivery.

Do you offer catering?

Yes! Valley Pizza offers catering for parties, office lunches, family gatherings, and other events. Our catering options include Catering - Garlic Knots, Catering - Garlic Knot Sliders, Wings, and other favorites.

Additionally, we offer delivery or on-site pickup.

Visit our catering page for more information.