Chicken Marsala Hero
$14.00
A hero sandwich filled with chicken and savory Marsala wine sauce.
“Great slices! Lots of options, garlic knots slider sandwiches look amazing. Will be back for more 🍕🍕🍕”
Sandwiches in Valley Cottage
Explore the full sandwiches menu at Valley Pizza in Valley Cottage, NY, with convenient pickup available for every craving.
Order online
Something for Everyone at Valley Pizza
Valley Pizza in Valley Cottage, NY offers a wide sandwiches selection, from hearty heroes to garlic knot sliders, giving you plenty of satisfying options to choose from.
Fan favorites include the Italian Combo Hero, Chicken Parm Hero, Veal Parm Hero, New Yorker Hero, Valley Special Hero, and the Monster Parm Hero, each a filling choice on its own.
Stop in for dine-in at Valley Pizza in Valley Cottage, NY, or place an order for pickup, delivery, or catering—however you prefer to enjoy your sandwiches.
Sandwiches to Try
Buffalo Chicken Parm Hero
$12.00
Hero sandwich with buffalo chicken, tomato sauce, and melted cheese.
Buffalo Chicken Roll
$9.00
A baked roll filled with Buffalo-seasoned chicken.
Buffalo Chicken Slider
$4.50
A small garlic-knot sandwich filled with Buffalo chicken.
Chicken Parm Roll
$9.00
A baked roll filled with chicken Parmesan-style ingredients.
Eggplant Parm Roll
$9.00
A baked sandwich roll filled with eggplant and Parmesan-style toppings.
Eggplant Parmigiana Slider
$4.50
Eggplant Parmigiana hero sandwich served on a garlic knot.
Frickin' Chicken Slider
$4.50
A chicken slider served on a garlic knot-style roll.
Italian Combo Slider
$4.50
An Italian combo slider served on a garlic knot.
Meatball Parm Hero
$12.00
Hero sandwich filled with meatballs, tomato sauce, and melted cheese.
Meatball Slider
$4.50
Meatball slider served on a garlic knot for a handheld bite.
Chicken Cordon Bleu Hero
$13.00
Chicken sandwich featuring the classic ham-and-cheese filling.
Chicken Cutlet Combo Hero
$12.00
A chicken cutlet hero sandwich with a combination-style filling.
Chicken Francese Hero
$14.00
Breaded chicken in lemon-butter sauce served on a hero roll.
Chicken Parm Hero
$12.00
A hero sandwich filled with chicken Parmesan-style ingredients.
Grilled Chicken Combo Hero
$12.00
Grilled chicken served in a combination hero sandwich.
Italian Combo Hero
$12.00
Italian-style combination hero sandwich in a long roll.
Monster Parm Hero
$25.00
Focaccia-style hero with a required choice of three fillings.
New Yorker Hero
$14.00
Chicken cutlet hero with American cheese, bacon, and Russian dressing.
Peppers & Egg Hero
$8.00
A hero sandwich filled with cooked peppers and egg.
Potato & Egg Hero
$8.00
A hero sandwich filled with potato and egg.
Sausage & Pepper Roll
$9.00
A baked roll filled with sausage and peppers for a handheld meal.
Sausage & Peppers Hero
$12.00
A hero sandwich filled with sausage and peppers.
Shrimp Parm Hero
$14.00
Breaded shrimp with marinara and melted cheese on a hero roll.
Slider Party Tray
$48.00+
Party tray of garlic knot sliders, available with 12 or 24 sliders.
Valley Special Hero
$14.00
Hero with grilled chicken, peppers, mozzarella, eggplant, and balsamic.
Veal Parm Hero
$14.00
Veal Parmesan hero sandwich served in a long Italian-style roll.
Veal, Pepper & Onion Hero
$14.00
Hero sandwich filled with veal, peppers, and onions.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are your most popular sandwiches options?
Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.
- Monster Parm Hero — Choose buffalo chicken, chicken Parmigiana, or eggplant Parmigiana as the filling for this focaccia-style hero sandwich.
- Slider Party Tray — Choose a small tray with 12 sliders or a large tray with 24 garlic knot sliders for group service.
- Valley Special Hero — Grilled chicken, roasted peppers, mozzarella, eggplant, and balsamic dressing fill this substantial Italian-style hero sandwich.
- Chicken Cutlet Combo Hero — This sandwich features a chicken cutlet in a hero roll, while the menu does not specify the combo fillings.
- Chicken Marsala Hero — The sandwich centers on chicken in savory Marsala wine sauce, served inside a hero roll.
Do you offer delivery and takeout?
Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for sandwiches throughout the Valley Cottage area. Order your sandwiches online for convenient pickup or delivery.
Do you offer catering?
Yes! Valley Pizza offers catering for parties, office lunches, family gatherings, and other events. Our catering options include Catering - Garlic Knot Sliders, Catering - Garlic Knots, Catering - Chicken Fingers, and other favorites.
Additionally, we offer delivery or on-site pickup.
Visit our catering page for more information.
