Sandwiches in Valley Cottage

Hero sandwiches and sliders at Valley Pizza in Valley Cottage, NY include Parm and Buffalo styles, with pickup available for your meal.

Order online

Subs

Meatball Parm Hero

$12.00

Meatballs, tomato sauce, and melted cheese fill this hero sandwich.

“Always have great pizza and heros...”

Chicken Marsala Hero

$14.00

Chicken in Marsala wine sauce fills a long hero sandwich roll.

Eggplant Parm Hero

$12.00

Eggplant Parmigiana with tomato sauce and cheese fills this hero sandwich.

Buffalo Chicken Parm Hero

$12.00

A hero sandwich with Buffalo-style chicken and Parmesan flavor.

Cheesesteak

Philly Cheese Steak Hero

$13.00

Sliced steak and melted cheese fill a long hero sandwich roll.

“Very clean, great customer service and the cheesesteak hero is amazing.”

Chicken Cheese Steak Hero

$13.00

Chicken cheesesteak and melted cheese fill a long hero roll.

Garlic Knot Sliders

Chicken Parmigiana Slider

$4.50

Chicken Parmesan served on garlic-knot bread as a small sandwich.

“SAFETY TOMS IS THE WAVE. THE GRANDMA SLICES HIT AS WELL AS THE SLIDERS HARDER THAN PRIME MIKE TYSON. 5 STARS ALL DAY NO QUESTION ABOUT IT MIGHT BE THE GREATEST IVE EVER HAD. IF I WAS ON DEATH ROW THIS WOULD BE MY LAST MEAL. VALLEY PIZZA> ANYTHING IN ROCKLAND ❗️❗️❗️❗️❗️❗️❗️❗️❗️❗️❗️❗️❗️❗️❗️❗️❗️”

Italian Combo Slider

$4.50

A small Italian combo sandwich served on a garlic knot.

“If you haven't eaten here yet you are definitely missing out, chef Tom's food is absolutely incredible, and I'm not just talking about one thing it's everything ask about his sliders and definitely try the pizza. The eggplant parmesan is to die for.”

Something for Everyone at Valley Pizza

Valley Pizza serves sandwiches in hero and slider formats, with parmigiana, francese and Marsala styles alongside Italian combinations, cheese steak sandwiches, and potato-and-egg fillings.

Try New Yorker Hero with chicken cutlet, American cheese, bacon and Russian dressing, Valley Special Hero with grilled chicken, roasted peppers and balsamic dressing, or Buffalo Chicken Slider.

Visit Valley Pizza in Valley Cottage, NY for pickup, dine-in or delivery. Monster Parm Hero comes on fresh-made 18-inch focaccia-style bread, with Buffalo chicken or eggplant Parm options.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular sandwiches options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

Philly Cheese Steak Hero — This hero centers on sliced steak and melted cheese in a long roll, following the familiar Philly cheesesteak sandwich style.
Meatball Parm Hero — A classic Italian-style hero, it combines meatballs with tomato sauce and melted cheese inside a long sandwich roll.
Slider Party Tray — Choose a small tray with 12 sliders or a large tray with 24; the listed tray size determines the quantity.
Chicken Parm Hero — This hero sandwich features breaded chicken with tomato sauce and cheese, combining the familiar components of chicken Parmesan.
Chicken Cutlet Combo Hero — A chicken cutlet fills a hero roll, making this a handheld sandwich with a familiar long shape.

Do you offer delivery and takeout?

Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for sandwiches throughout the Valley Cottage area. Order your sandwiches online for convenient pickup or delivery.