Sicilian Food in Valley Cottage

Sicilian food in slices or an 18-inch pizza awaits you at Valley Pizza in Valley Cottage, NY, with pickup available for your order.

Order online

Sicilian Food to Try

18" Sicilian Pizza

An 18-inch Sicilian pizza cut into eight slices.

Sausage & Vodka Sauce Sicilian Pizza$28.00Topped with sausage and vodka sauce on an 18-inch Sicilian pizza cut into eight slices.
Anchovy, Olive, Mushroom & Garlic Sicilian Pizza$38.50Light sauce with anchovies, olives, extra cheese, garlic, and mushrooms on an 18-inch Sicilian pizza.
Pepperoni Sicilian Pizza$24.50Topped with pepperoni on an 18-inch Sicilian pizza cut into eight slices.
Mushroom, Pepper & Onion Sicilian Pizza$31.50Topped with mushrooms, peppers, and onions on an 18-inch Sicilian pizza cut into eight slices.
Chicken & Broccoli Sicilian Pizza$28.00Topped with chicken and broccoli on an 18-inch Sicilian pizza cut into eight slices.

“Some of the best pizza I have ever had in my life!!! The young lady on the phone named Melody was very kind, and we had a nice conversation about life before ordering my pizza. I highly suggest coming here for good prices, excellent service, and for a wholesome meal.”

Sicilian Slice

$4.00

A thick-crust Sicilian pizza slice has a soft, breadlike base.

“Friendly staff, cute little place with delicious pizza”

Sicilian Slice with 1 Topping

$4.50

A Sicilian-style pizza slice with one topping.

Made with Care at Valley Pizza

At Valley Pizza, Sicilian food centers on pizza, with individual slices alongside a full pie. The slice offerings include a topping option, and toppings are also available for the whole pizza.

For an individual portion, order Sicilian Slice; Sicilian Slice with 1 Topping includes a single topping. The 18" Sicilian Pizza is the full-size choice alongside those by-the-slice options.

Visit Valley Pizza in Valley Cottage, NY, for pickup, dine-in, or delivery. Your whole pizza comes cut into eight slices, with topping options including pepperoni, mushrooms, garlic, and extra cheese.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular Sicilian food options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

18" Sicilian Pizza — An 18-inch Sicilian-style pizza is cut into eight slices, with optional toppings available to customize each order.
Sicilian Slice with 1 Topping — This Sicilian-style slice includes one topping on a thick-crust pizza cut from a larger pie.
Sicilian Slice — This Sicilian-style slice has a thick, airy crust, giving it a substantial base beneath its pizza toppings.

Do you offer delivery and takeout?

Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for sicilian food throughout the Valley Cottage area. Order your sicilian food online for convenient pickup or delivery.